The new season of The Paper kicks off with a celebration that quickly turns awkward — and that tone-setting moment hints at bigger changes ahead.
A party, a punchline, and a jolt that changes the mood
The premiere of season 2 on SkyShowtime opens on the Toledo Truth Teller newsroom in high spirits after winning journalism awards. That celebratory atmosphere is disrupted when staffers learn that someone connected to Softee, the toilet-paper company, has died. The sequence works as more than a joke: it signals that this season intends to push into different territory, balancing comedy with storylines that steer the show toward fresh ground.

Writers shifting gears and testing new directions
Under Greg Daniels and Michael Koman, the writers appear to be deliberately expanding the series’ scope. The rivalry and petty competitions that helped drive season 1 are receding; instead, season 2 experiments with character dynamics and long-form relationship threads. The new focus suggests the creative team is searching for the show’s next big move rather than repeating the same template.
The central relationship that holds the season together
Much of the season’s momentum comes from the push-and-pull between Ned (Domhnall Gleeson) and Mare (Chelsea Frei). Their uncertain status — whether they’re an actual couple, just a workplace fling, or something in between — becomes a spine for many episodes. How that relationship evolves is a recurring question that the show returns to as it explores both romantic and professional boundaries.
How character design affects the mockumentary feel
One structural challenge the series continues to face stems from its cast choices. Unlike The Office, which often anchored its mockumentary format with relatively ordinary characters who reveal quirks over time, The Paper leans into figures who are strikingly eccentric from the start. That intensity can weaken the faux-documentary illusion and create emotional distance between viewers and characters — a gap that didn’t exist as much with Jim and Pam’s interplay in Daniels’ earlier work.

Missed opportunities among supporting players and subplots
Some supporting characters seem undervalued, which leaves room for improvement. For example, giving Adam a larger role could diversify the ensemble’s chemistry. At the same time, certain storylines feel unnecessary; the human-resources video subplot, and some of Esmeralda’s arcs, don’t always land and might be pared back or retooled to better serve the season’s rhythm.
Bigger laughs, memorable beats, and a show still finding its stride
Despite these issues, season 2 is often funnier and more energetic than its predecessor. Episodes deliver frequent laughs and a handful of standout sequences, suggesting the series has room to grow. Throughout, the writers toss out ideas in a way that resembles an active brainstorming session — testing tones, relationships, and formats as they look for the shape that will let the show fully realize its potential.
Similar Posts
- ‘The Office’ Sequel Triumphs Before Release: ‘The Paper’ Renewed for Season 2!
- Greg Daniels on ‘The Paper’: How Season One Stands Strong Alone!
- Discover the Next Big Hit in Comedy: “The Paper” Delivers Comfort and Laughs!
- Netflix Thriller Returns Today: Short, Addictive Series Where Every Season Tops the Last
- Bad News for ‘Wednesday’ Fans: Season 3 with Jenna Ortega Delayed on Netflix

Avery Sandridge has an unmatched love for storytelling and the screen. From detailed analyses of your favorite shows to behind-the-scenes scoops, Avery offers a fresh and engaging take on everything TV series.